Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

1. Chernobyl disaster was not related in any way with nuclear plant normal functioning. It was "experiment of how low output reactor can go" proposed and exercised by people without knowledge or experience. It's monument of why government officials should not touch anything related to science

2. Chernobyl nuclear plant was very poor copy of safe by design nuclear plant. It had critical flaw in carbon based proton catching mechanism

3. Closed zone is currently habitable (except Sarcophagus area). You'll receive much higher radiation dose simply by flying to Norway. Nature is returning there, there're plans to repopulate it

4. This was in Soviet Union and power plant was "public". Most of the power plant in EU is public if not every single one. I don't have exact information on this topic

Please do not treat entire technology, which is safe, as a threat simply because some greedy, uneducated people from the past wanted better position and paid ultimate price for it

 help



> some greedy, uneducated people from the past wanted better position

We don't have greedy, uneducated people who want better positions now?


And died horrendous dead? Because guy who did this was in nuclear plant and was buried in lead coffin in closed zone.

His skin was falling from body while he was still breathing


The Chernobyl disaster wasn't caused by a single person, as you note in your comment "proposed and exercised by people without knowledge or experience."

And how many people who were on site survived and for how long?

There were lots on the site, which I thinks shows how weak your "which is safe" point is.

If there were lots of people there AND it still happened then.. not very safe right?


What is carbon based proton catching mechanism?

I suppose a graphite moderator would fit the description.

Exactly, sorry for bad description



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: