Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Anyone can put anything on arxiv, it counts the same as printing it on tissue paper.
 help



Not really. It's not peer reviewed, but it's also not a free-for-all repository.

If you make a new account, you either have to get someone to vouch for you, or you have to wait arXiv mods to look carefully through your first few preprints. If you are found to post pseudoscience, overly fringe theories, etc., you'll get banned from arXiv; that's why alternative repositories like vixRa.org popped up.

But I know why you think this; when I first joined arXiv many years, there were no such checks in place, at least not that I can remember.


I also don't remember checks, but I believe that having an email address of an approved organization was enough to pass.

No. You do have checks, it's just that once you publish 4-5 papers, 99% of your field is open to you so you never have to do the checks again.

>Anyone

Strangely enough, the crackpots seems to prefer vixra.org to publish their work. I've never seen something like "4D wormholes can cure cancer" in ArXiv




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: